Table 3. Thinning and final cutting removals (m3 ha–1) by timber assortments using alternative rotation lengths of 55–85 years in the four different treatments without and with the simulated late thinning at the age of 60 years. * indicates significantly (p < 0.05) higher volume of saw logs (incl. grade A butt logs) in the plots of quality thinning compared with the other treatments using the same rotation period.
Cutting removals, m3 ha–1
Timber assortment First thinning Delayed first thinning Second thinning Alternative final cutting without late thinning Late
thinning
Alternative final cutting with late thinning
Stand age, years
30 40 45 55 60 65 70 75 80 60 70 75 80 85
Thinning from below
Pulpwood 32 26 71 77 83 90 93 99 16 73 77 82 86
Small-diameter saw logs 16 28 24 21 17 14 12 8 9 7 5 4
Conventional saw logs 7 105 143 172 199 226 251 23 172 196 218 240
Grade A butt logs 0 1 1 1 1 3 4 0 2 3 5 5
Total 32 49 205 245 277 307 336 366 47 256 283 310 335
Quality thinning
Pulpwood 35 32 50 52 54 57 58 61 16 39 42 44 46
Small-diameter saw logs 15 47 40 35 30 26 23 13 17 14 11 9
Conventional saw logs 6 118 167 *203 *235 *268 *297 31 *198 *225 *249 *272
Grade A butt logs 0 1 3 *4 *8 *10 *13 0 *8 *12 *18 *23
Total 35 53 216 262 296 330 362 394 60 262 293 322 350
Thinning from above + pruning
Pulpwood 36 36 73 78 80 85 89 92 25 58 60 63 66
Small-diameter saw logs 9 46 42 42 38 34 31 9 27 24 20 17
Conventional saw logs 9 92 131 153 175 198 220 30 139 159 181 203
Grade A butt logs 2 4 15 26 37 48 57 2 42 54 63 71
Total 36 56 215 266 301 335 369 400 66 266 297 327 357
Delayed first thinning
Pulpwood 72 84 93 100 103 110 116 27 76 81 85 90
Small-diameter saw logs 22 35 30 26 25 21 18 8 16 13 10 8
Conventional saw logs 9 93 139 169 197 225 252 25 168 195 221 244
Grade A butt logs 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 2
Total 103 212 262 296 326 357 387 60 261 290 317 344