Table 1. Sampling criteria and number of trees and shrubs sampled per species. Among the five dominant woody species of LSR’s savanna, two (Crossopteryx febrifuga and Cussonia arborea) grow only in a typical single-stemmed tree, two (Piliostigma thonningii and Bridelia ferruginea) grow both as a single-stemmed tree or as a multi-stemmed shrub and one (Annona senegalensis) grows exclusively as a shrub. | |||||
Species | Shrubs | Trees | Total | ||
n | N | Db (cm) | N | ||
A. senegalensis | 3–5 | 15 | - | - | 30 |
A. senegalensis | 6–10 | 10 | - | - | |
A. senegalensis | >10 | 5 | - | - | |
B. Ferruginea | 3–5 | 15 | <10 | 10 | 55 |
B. Ferruginea | 6–10 | 10 | 10–15 | 10 | |
B. Ferruginea | >10 | 5 | >15 | 5 | |
C. Febrifuga | - | - | <10 | 10 | 25 |
C. Febrifuga | - | - | 10–15 | 10 | |
C. Febrifuga | - | - | >15 | 5 | |
C. arborea | - | - | <10 | 10 | 25 |
C. arborea | - | - | 10–15 | 10 | |
C. arborea | - | - | >15 | 5 | |
P. thonningii | 3–5 | 15 | <10 | 10 | 55 |
P. thonningii | 6–10 | 10 | 10–15 | 10 | |
P. thonningii | >10 | 5 | >15 | 5 | |
Total | 90 | 100 | N = 190 | ||
n: number of stems per individual; N: number of samples; Db: stem basal diameter. |
Table 2. Effects of growth form, w (ρDb2H in g cm–1 m) and n (total number of stems) and their interaction on the estimation of the aboveground and belowground biomass (AGB and BGB) in Lamto trees and shrubs. For trees, Db (cm) corresponds to the stem basal diameter and H (m) represents the total height in the term ρDb2H. For shrubs, the term Db2H corresponds to the sum of di2hi (i = 1…n) of the n stems, where di (cm) and hi (m) are respectively the basal diameter and the total height of each stem. ρ (g cm–3) is the woody specific density. | ||||
Dependent variables | Source of variation | Mean Sq | F value | P value |
ln(AGB) | Growth form | 242.31 | 1021.72 | <0.001*** |
ln(w) | 332.04 | 1400.05 | <0.001*** | |
ln(n) | 11.07 | 46.68 | <0.001*** | |
Growth form: ln(w) | 2.55 | 10.74 | <0.01** | |
ln(BGB) | Growth form | 107.24 | 356.31 | <0.001*** |
ln(w) | 214.84 | 713.83 | <0.001*** | |
ln(n) | 23.10 | 76.75 | <0.001*** | |
Growth form: ln(w) | 0.03 | 0.09 | >0.05 |
Table 3. Regression parameters of the fitted allometric models for predicting above- and belowground biomass (AGB and BGB in kg) of trees and shrubs measured in the Guinean savanna of Lamto Scientific Reserve. Variable w corresponds to the product ρDb2H (g cm–1 m) and variable n represents the total number of stems. For trees, Db (cm) corresponds to the stem basal diameter and H (m) represents the total height in the term ρDb2H. For shrubs, the term Db2H corresponds to the sum of di2hi (i = 1…n) of the n stems, where di (cm) and hi (m) are respectively the basal diameter and the total height of each stem. ρ (g cm–3) is the woody specific density. Values in brackets = standard error (se) of the estimated value; Adj-R2 = Adjusted R square; AIC = Akaike information criterion; CF = Correction factor due to logarithmic transformation; a, b and c are constants and represent the regression coefficients of the models. | |||||||
Model | Regression coefficients | Adj-R2 | AIC | CF | |||
a (se) | b (se) | c (se) | |||||
Trees | ln(AGB) = a + b ln(w) | –3.2191 (0.18) *** | 0.9150 (0.03) *** | - | 0.90 | 176.19 | 1.1780 |
ln(BGB) = a + b ln(w) | –2.2527 (0.18) *** | 0.6899 (0.03) *** | - | 0.82 | 181 | 1.1875 | |
Shrubs | ln(AGB) = a + b ln(w) + c ln(n) | –4.0272 (0.17) *** | 0.6227 (0.06) *** | 0.9271 (0.09) *** | 0.84 | 80.27 | 1.0699 |
ln(BGB) = a + b ln (w) + c ln(n) | –3.9059 (0.23) *** | 0.7205 (0.09) *** | 0.9920 (0.13) *** | 0.77 | 136.56 | 1.1347 |
Table 4. Difference between species of the regression parameters of the fitted allometric models for predicting above- and belowground biomass (AGB and BGB in kg) of trees and shrubs measured in the Lamto Scientific Reserve. Variable w corresponds to the product ρDb2H (g cm–1 m) and variable n represents the total number of stems. For trees, Db (cm) corresponds to the stem basal diameter and H (m) represents the total height in the term ρDb2H. For shrubs, the term Db2H corresponds to the sum of di2hi (i = 1…n) of the n stems, where di (cm) and hi (m) are respectively the basal diameter and the total height of each stem. ρ (g cm–3) is the woody specific density. Values in brackets = standard error (se) of the estimated value; Adj-R2 = Adjusted R square; CF = Correction factor due to logarithmic transformation; a, b and c are constants and represent the regression coefficients of the models. | |||||||
Growth form | Model for biomass prediction | Species | Regression coefficients | Adj-R2 | CF | ||
a (se) | b (se) | c (se) | |||||
Trees | ln(AGB) = a + b ln(w) | B. ferruginea | –1.9674 (0.32) *** | 0.7226 (0.06) *** | - | 0.86 | 1.0822 |
C. febrifuga | –4.1332 (0.24) *** | 0.1000 (0.04) *** | - | 0.96 | 1.1059 | ||
C. arborea | –3.2339 (0.39) *** | 0.9374 (0.07) ** | - | 0.87 | 1.2743 | ||
P. thonningii | –3.1290 (0.28) *** | 0.9167 (0.05) *** | - | 0.94 | 1.0293 | ||
ln(BGB) = a + b ln(w) | B. ferruginea | –1.7230 (0.38) *** | 0.6116 (0.07) *** | - | 0.76 | 1.1176 | |
C. febrifuga | –3.0946 (0.18) *** | 0.7650 (0.03) *** | - | 0.97 | 1.0564 | ||
C. arborea | –1.8752 (0.40) *** | 0.5928 (0.08) ** | - | 0.71 | 1.2989 | ||
P. thonningii | –2.1070 (0.26) *** | 0.7361 (0.05) *** | - | 0.91 | 1.0678 | ||
Shrubs | ln(AGB) = a + b ln(w) + c ln(n) | A. senegalensis | –4.4805 (0.20) *** | 0.8738 (0.10) *** | 0.8865 (0.12) *** | 0.94 | 1.0264 |
B. ferruginea | –3.3522 (0.24) *** | 0.7027 (0.07) *** | 0.5083 (0.12) *** | 0.86 | 1.0463 | ||
P. thonningii | –4.2124 (0.20) *** | 0.1112 (0.13) >0.05 | 1.7147 (0.17) *** | 0.94 | 1.0293 | ||
ln(BGB) = a + b ln (w) + c ln(n) | A. senegalensis | –4.5151 (0.37) *** | 1.0006 (0.19) *** | 1.0992 (0.22) *** | 0.86 | 1.0954 | |
B. ferruginea | –3.4570 (0.29) *** | 0.8295 (0.08) *** | 0.5008 (0.14) ** | 0.84 | 1.0718 | ||
P. thonningii | –3.8090 (0.37) *** | 0.3054 (0.24) >0.05 | 1.5140 (0.30) *** | 0.84 | 1.0989 |
Table 5. Comparison of model accuracy between the allometric models fitted to trees and shrubs measurements of the savanna of Lamto Scientific Reserve and the allometric equations adjusted by Ifo et al. (2018) from trees measurements in the savanna of the Plateau Batéké in Congo basin. The variable w corresponds to the product ρDb2H (g cm–1 m), where Db (cm) and H (m) respectively represent the stem basal diameter and the total height in trees; and in shrubs the term Db2H corresponds to the sum of di2hi (i = 1…n) of the n stems (di = basal diameter in cm; hi = total height of each stem in m). ρ (g cm–3) is the woody specific density. Written alone, Db (cm) corresponds to the stem basal diameter for trees and to the equivalent basal diameter of stems for shrubs (see Eq. 1 for detail relative to the measure of the equivalent basal diameter in shrubs). | ||||
Models fitted in this study | Ifo et al. (2018) models | |||
Trees | Shrubs | Trees | Shrubs | |
Model | AGB = 4.71 10–2 (w)0.9150 | AGB = 1.91 10–2 (w)0.6227 (n)0.9271 | AGB = 9.31 10–2 (w)0.9135 | |
Model bias (%) | 19.04 | 1.48 | 132.48 | 78.76 |
Model | BGB = 1.25 10–1 (w)0.6899 | BGB = 2.28 10–2 (w)0.7205 (n)0.9920 | BGB = 12.58 10–2 (ρDb2)0.8640 | |
Model bias (%) | 6.04 | 2.70 | 2.65 | –14.05 |