Table 1. Clones included in the study (origin from a clone test (Stener 2004)).
Clone ID a) Taxon Dbh d)
(cm)
No. of stumps Additional information
Co1 (5) P. maximowiczii b) × P. trichocarpa b) 40.1 7 USA, Commercial name ‘Androscoggin’
Co2 (4) P. maximowiczii × P. nigra b) 36.5 10 USA, Commercial name ‘Rochester’
Co3 (113) P. maximowiczii × P. trichocarpa 46.3 4 USA
Co4 (8) Balsam type c) 36.5 4 Unknown origin
Co5 (122) P. trichocarpa 35 4 Br. Columbia, Canada
Co6 (108) P. trichocarpa 32 4 Br. Columbia, Canada
Co7 (97) P. trichocarpa 29.7 3 Alaska, USA
Co8 (38) Balsam type c) 38.8 4 Unknown origin
Ca1 (87) P. trichocarpa 36.7 3 Washington, USA
Ca2 (37) P. deltoides b) × P. nigra 35.3 3 Unknown origin
Ca3 (67) P. trichocarpa 30.4 5 Br. Columbia, Canada
Ca4 (103) P. trichocarpa 31 4 Br. Columbia, Canada
Ca5 (50) P. trichocarpa 29.4 5 Br. Columbia, Canada
Ca6 (111) P. trichocarpa 34.8 4 Br. Columbia, Canada
Ca7 (92) P. trichocarpa 29 4 Br. Columbia, Canada
1 (51) P. trichocarpa 26.8 4 Oregon, USA
2 (2) P. deltoides × P. trichocarpa 38.3 4 Wageningen, Netherlands, Commercial name ‘Barn’
3 (45) P. trichocarpa 26.3 4 Washington, USA
4 (104) P. trichocarpa 25.8 4 Washington, USA
5 (54) P. trichocarpa 25.6 5 Oregon, USA
6 (66) P. trichocarpa 23.8 5 Br. Columbia, Canada
7 (96) P. trichocarpa 29.3 4 Oregon, USA
8 (121) P. trichocarpa 19.3 4 Br. Columbia, Canada
a) Commercial clones start with clone ID ‘Co’, candidates start with ‘Ca’ and additional clones are numbered in the bottom. In parentheses Skogforsk’s ID is given.
b) P. maximowiczii Henry, P. trichocarpa Torr. & Gary, P. deltoides Marsh., P. nigra L.
c) Unknown clones of P. trichocarpa, P. balsamifera L. or hybrids of these two species.
d) Dbh refers to the felled trees.
1

Fig. 1. The relative frequency of stump survival (meaning stumps supporting live sprouts). For clone information, see Table 1.

2

Fig. 2. Sprout straightness (white = straight (class 1), grey = crooked (class 2), black = severely crooked (class 3)). Numbers on top represent the mean number of sprouts per stump. For clone information, see Table 1.

3

Fig. 3. Quartile range box of number of sprouts per stump. Vertical lines are the upper and lower whiskers, representing the boarders of the data. Top line in the box is the third quartile, middle line is the median, and bottom line is the first quartile. Mean value is shown by a diamond. For clone information, see Table 1.