Table 1. Keywords used in the risk identification process.
Theme Keywords
Business profitability, solvency, cost calculation, pricing, investment planning, invoicing
Contracts own contractual obligations and rights, attractiveness as contract partner, partners, lack of contracts
Services/ products machine manufacturers, maintenance services, insurance, financing, accounting
Production work on site, planning, interruptions, waste management, theft and vandalism, logistics, transfers
Machines/ premises forest machines, transfer trucks, machine halls, storage, storage of dangerous materials
Culture new operational environment, attitudes of local people, adaptation to the local business environment, differences in organisational culture and behaviour
Entrepreneur key person risk, own knowledge and management, work motivation, economic conditions, family, use of time
Personnel preconditions for working, professional skills, traffic, work safety, welfare at work, local labour, communication, work culture, health care
Markets demand, business cycle, dependency on clients, competition, clients’ solvency, payment schedules, clients’ demands
Policy and
authorities
political stability, legislation, customs clearance, taxation, working permissions, other permissions, supervision, regional practices
Infrastructure road network, phone network, IT network, sites, accommodation
Natural
conditions
storms, frost, rainy seasons, frost heave, animals, quality of forest resources
Table 2. Probability of risk.
Rate Probability Interpretation
1 Remote Happens once in 50 years or less frequently
2 Unlikely At most once in 10 years
3 Possible At most once in 5 years
4 Likely Once in a year
5 Very likely More than once in a year
Table 3. Consequences of risk.
Rate Economic loss Interruption of work Personal injury
0 No loss No interruption No injuries
1 < €5 000 < 2 days Mild injury of one person
2 €5 000–€9 999 < 1 week Mild injury of several people
3 €10 000–€49 999 < 1 month Serious injury of one person (permanent injury)
4 €50 000–€99 999 < 3 months Serious injury of several people (permanent injury)
5 €100 000–€300 000 < 5 months Death of one person
6 > €300 000 > 6 months Death of several people
Table 4. Consequence/probability matrix for producing risk level.
Probability Consequence
1 2 3 4 5 6
5 Very likely II III IV V V V
4 Likely II III III IV V V
3 Possible I II III IV IV V
2 Unlikely I II III III IV V
1 Remote I I II III IV IV
Table 5. Action plan for risk treatment (Koneyrityksen riskienhallinta 2007).
Risk severity Action
1. Trivial Risk is so small that no action is needed
2. Minor Action is not necessarily needed
Situation has to be followed to be able to control it
3. Moderate Action is needed to check or clarify the situation
Action is possibly needed
4. Serious Necessary to reduce risk, but taking into account social, economic, and other aspects
Action is needed
5. Extreme Removing or reducing risk is necessary regardless of costs
If reducing risk is not possible, work should be forbidden permanently
Table 6. Possible risks for Finnish wood harvesting contractors in Russia.
Theme Risk
Business Breaches of contract by client
Dependency on client, limited number of potential clients
Low profitability of business
Machines, premises, and production Availability and professionalism of service
Changing production volumes make planning difficult and decrease profitability
Problems in operational planning caused by interruptions in work between harvesting sites
Availability of spare parts
Theft of equipment and supplies
Machinery and hall fires
Personnel and
culture
Inadequate know-how of the entrepreneur regarding Russian conditions
Workers’ inadequate professional skills and ability to work independently
Difficulties in supervision of work due to different mindset (ideas about right and wrong, agreeing, respecting others’ property)
Misunderstandings caused by interpretation of foreign language
Neglecting one’s own and others’ safety
Use of alcohol during work hours
Markets Sensitivity to general economic fluctuations
Lack of financing
Underpricing competitors
Policy and
authorities
Non-transparent procedures of the authorities, unpredictability of the authorities (interpretation of legislation, waiting for inspections)
Quick and unexpected changes of laws and regulations
Inflexible practice of receiving permissions
Forest fires not extinguished, danger for people and machinery
Infrastructure and natural conditions Long frost heave period causing downtime
Roads are not ploughed in winter, no access to harvesting site
Unpredictable time consumption and productivity due to the changing structure of forests
Help is not available quickly in cases of sickness and injury
1

Fig. 1. Sources of common economic risk regarding payment defaults in contracting in Russia.