Berit H. Lindstad, Birger Solberg. (2010). Assessing national compliance with international forest policy processes – the role of subjective judgments. Silva Fennica vol. 44 no. 1 article id 167. https://doi.org/10.14214/sf.167

Keywords: sustainable forest management; multiple objectives; implementation; participatory process

Abstract | View details | Full text in PDF | Author Info

Several international policy processes with sustainable forest management (SFM) as a common goal have emerged during the past two decades. Based on an empirical study from Norway, this paper analyses the role of subjective judgments in assessing national compliance with three international forest policy processes, and the implications for determination of the effects of these processes. The Expanded Programme of Work on Forest Biological Diversity, the Ministerial Conference on the Protection of Forests in Europe and the United Nations Forum on Forests, including its predecessors, collectively provide more than 600 recommendations for SFM. While it is nothing new that SFM encompasses value questions, this paper is a systematic review of where in a process of assessing national compliance the role of judgments is most profound. The paper shows that the multiple objectives of the forest recommendations, references to national circumstances and provisions for stakeholder involvement lead to differing opinions about the degree of conformity between international recommendations and national situation, i.e. compliance. These differing opinions mean different prospects for the international processes to have effects, because only implementation, or active responses to international recommendations, constitutes effects. The roles of judgments and values are recommended topics for further investigation. Factors influencing how compliance is assessed, and consequently the degree to which implementation is deemed necessary, require specific attention. Due consideration to substantive and methodological choices in determining national changes and in separation of other sources of influence will provide a better basis for informed discussion of compliance with and effects of international forest-related policy processes.

Lindstad, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Department of Ecology and Natural Resource Management, Ås, Norway E-mail: berit.lindstad@umb.no
Solberg, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Department of Ecology and Natural Resource Management, Ås, Norway E-mail: bs@nn.no

Click this link to register to Silva Fennica.

If you are a registered user, log in to save your selected articles for later access.

Contents alert

Your selected articles
Send to email

Pukkala T., Holt Hanssen K. et al. (2019) Stem taper and bark functions for Norway spruce .. Silva Fennica vol. 53 no. 3 article id 10187 (remove) | Edit comment

Rinkinen I., (1964) Waste wood of the Finnish sawmill industry. A st.. Silva Fennica vol. no. 115 article id 4718 (remove) | Edit comment

Loh D. K., Saarenmaa H. (1992) Design of integrated forest resource information.. Silva Fennica vol. 26 no. 2 article id 5479 (remove) | Edit comment

Sievänen R., Nikinmaa E. et al. (1997) Evaluation of importance of sapwood senescence o.. Silva Fennica vol. 31 no. 3 article id 5629 (remove) | Edit comment

Sarvas R., (1937) Observations on development of vegetation in bur.. Silva Fennica vol. no. 44 article id 4524 (remove) | Edit comment

Palo M., (1972) Competition among tractor-digger contractors and.. Acta Forestalia Fennica vol. 0 no. 126 article id 7560 (remove) | Edit comment

Ilvessalo L., (1927) Cultivation of exotic tree species Silva Fennica vol. no. 4 article id 4442 (remove) | Edit comment

Wegelius T., (1959) Survey of forest technology research in Finland Acta Forestalia Fennica vol. 70 no. 8 article id 7498 (remove) | Edit comment

Kangas Y., (1966) Felling volume and its structure in the Finnish .. Silva Fennica vol. no. 120 article id 4734 (remove) | Edit comment

Krott M., (1986) The politics of forest bureaucracy as a subject .. Silva Fennica vol. 20 no. 4 article id 5284 (remove) | Edit comment

Finnish Society of Forest Science ., (1984) Development programme for forestry research in F.. Silva Fennica vol. 18 no. 4 article id 5224 (remove) | Edit comment

Ruha T., Varmola M. (1997) Precommercial thinning in naturally regenerated .. Silva Fennica vol. 31 no. 4 article id 5635 (remove) | Edit comment

Keltikangas M., (1986) Quantification problems in the design of forest .. Silva Fennica vol. 20 no. 4 article id 5286 (remove) | Edit comment

Raatikainen M., (1978) The berry yield, picking, and marketing of Vacci.. Silva Fennica vol. 12 no. 2 article id 4996 (remove) | Edit comment

Metsähallitus ., (1938) Professional development courses of foresters in.. Silva Fennica vol. no. 46 article id 4525 (remove) | Edit comment

Sainio P., (1955) Winter nutrition of elk Silva Fennica vol. no. 88 article id 4647 (remove) | Edit comment

Kellomäki S., (1981) Effect of the within-stand light conditions on t.. Silva Fennica vol. 15 no. 2 article id 5111 (remove) | Edit comment

Ervasti S., (1960) The position of forest products in advertising o.. Silva Fennica vol. 0 no. 104 article id 4694 (remove) | Edit comment

Uotila K., Rantala J. et al. (2012) Estimating the need for early cleaning in Norway.. Silva Fennica vol. 46 no. 5 article id 919 (remove) | Edit comment

Abetz K., (1954) Derivation of the taxation value of forest in th.. Acta Forestalia Fennica vol. 61 no. 25 article id 7438 (remove) | Edit comment

Ripatti P., (2000) Use of log-linear models in forecasting structur.. Silva Fennica vol. 34 no. 3 article id 631 (remove) | Edit comment

Romakkaniemi-Niemelä P., (1985) RC-value of stem tissue of silver birch as an in.. Silva Fennica vol. 19 no. 2 article id 5236 (remove) | Edit comment

Deleuze C., Houllier F. (1997) A transport model for tree ring width. Silva Fennica vol. 31 no. 3 article id 5622 (remove) | Edit comment

Tuhti R., (1938) Promotion of agriculture and forestry in Finland Silva Fennica vol. no. 46 article id 4527 (remove) | Edit comment

Hari P., Heikinheimo P. et al. (1986) Trees as a water transport system. Silva Fennica vol. 20 no. 3 article id 5274 (remove) | Edit comment

Franssila M., (1958) The dependence of forest fire danger on meteorol.. Acta Forestalia Fennica vol. 67 no. 5 article id 7479 (remove) | Edit comment

Kellomäki S., Kolström M. (1992) Computations on the management of seedling stand.. Silva Fennica vol. 26 no. 2 article id 5478 (remove) | Edit comment

Simula M., (1985) Forestry and development - a global viewpoint. Silva Fennica vol. 19 no. 4 article id 5248 (remove) | Edit comment

Hall F.G., Sellers P.J. et al. (1996) Initial results from the boreal ecosystem-atmosp.. Silva Fennica vol. 30 no. 2–3 article id 5579 (remove) | Edit comment

Piha A., (1954) Taxation of state woodlands Acta Forestalia Fennica vol. 61 no. 31 article id 7443 (remove) | Edit comment

Juntunen M.-L., Engsås J. et al. (1985) Supervisors in the forestry of the Nordic countr.. Silva Fennica vol. 19 no. 1 article id 5229 (remove) | Edit comment

Kaila E., (1985) Observation manipulation and data matrix derivat.. Silva Fennica vol. 19 no. 1 article id 5230 (remove) | Edit comment

Huikari O., (1952) Determination of peatland type considering their.. Silva Fennica vol. no. 75 article id 4625 (remove) | Edit comment

Heikinheimo O., (1915) The effect of shifting cultivation on forests in.. Acta Forestalia Fennica vol. 4 no. 2 article id 7534 (remove) | Edit comment

Ervasti S., (1963) Seasonal variation in the sawmill industry of Fi.. Acta Forestalia Fennica vol. 76 no. 1 article id 7141 (remove) | Edit comment

Follow @SilvaFennica